Parlor Politics: In Which the Ladies of Washington Help Build a City and a Government

by Catherine Allgor

an excerpt from Parlor Politics

 

 

 


EXCERPTS FROM PARLOR POLITICS

"PRESIDENT JEFFERSON IN WASHINGTON CITY"

(from Chapter 1)

[After Jefferson has greeted the new First Minister to the United States from Great Britain, Anthony Merry, for the first time "actually standing in slippers down at the heels," which during their interview he "tossed. . . up in the air and caught. . . with his big toe," Merry arrives at a state dinner presumably given in his honor]

[The Merrys] first shock, upon entering the room, was discovering Louis Andre Pichon, the French charge d'affaires. England and France were at war, after all, and diplomatic custom should have prevented the social and political awkwardness of their common presence. Jefferson's flouting of this convention, the Merrys would soon learn, originated not in unstudied ignorance but in deliberate planning. The president had gone so far as to press Pichon to cut short his business in Baltimore in order to attend.

The spark that would ignite the flames of the etiquette war came when dinner was announced. According to social and diplomatic custom, Jefferson should have led the way, escorting the lady of honor, Mrs. Merry, followed by Mr. Merry and the lady of second rank, Mrs. Madison. . . . Instead, at the announcement Jefferson took the arm of the lady next to him, Dolley Payne Todd Madison, and escorted her into dinner, though Dolley demurred, whispering, "Take Mrs. Merry." The other guests were dumbfounded. The wife of the Spanish minister, born Sally McKean of Philadelphia, declared to Dolley, "This will be the cause of war!" Madison led Elizabeth Merry into the dining room, leaving the flabbergasted Anthony Merry to scramble for a seat. As he reached for a respectable place near the wife of the Spanish minister, an agile congressman slid past him and claimed the spot. . . . The British minister called for his carriage as soon as the meal was over.

 

"DOLLEY MADISON TAKES COMMAND"

(from Chapter 2)

[An imposing and elegant woman in appearance as well as in persona, Dolley Madison dressed and entertained regally, and often found herself--as at the first Inaugural Ball--"almost pressed to death" by a crowd eager to have "a peep at her."]

Dolley also dominated a more ordinary social form, the state dinner. Thomas Jefferson held his small dinners frequently, but the Madisons' versions were more lavish events, held once a week, and included as many as thirty guests. . . . These occasions took time and money, but all Washington hosts and guests recognized them as "powerful political factors. . .and even more so under the tactful sway of 'Queen Dolly'." Dolley restored enough ceremony for the proceedings to go forward smoothly but insisted on an informal atmosphere. In contrast to Jefferson's almost paranoid use of dumbwaiters to ensure his control over the proceedings, at a Madison dinner a slave or servant stood behind each guest to assure proper, personal service.

At these official dinners Dolley, quite contrary to custom, took the seat at the head of the table, placing Edward Coles, James's secretary and her kinsman, at the foot. Surprisingly, though many observers commented on this startling sight, none expressed censure or disapproval. Several pointed out that the arrangement spared the president from leading the conversation, pouring wine, or seeing to his guests' needs. Casual observers and close friends agreed that James, quite convivial in small groups, fell silent in large companies. Dolley, on the other hand, flourished as the leader of the table, directing the flow of conversation, expressing her own opinions to legislators, and persuading them to accept her husband's views. If she was not always successful in this endeavor, she went far toward softening her husband's rivals.

 

"MRS. ADAMS CAMPAIGNS FOR THE PRESIDENCY"

(from Chapter 4)

[During the era of the early Republic, no one ran for national office; there were no speeches, rallies, or events. A candidate could write to the newspaper under the guise of supplying biographical information (as John Quincy did) or explaining a political position (as Calhoun did), but the chief method of assuring one's nomination was to arouse the zeal of one's political friends and, through a network of supporters, create a favorable image of one's self in the public mind. Parties, balls, dinners, and White House drawing-room receptions were ideal for this purpose.]

As the 1824 election neared, society divided into "separate battalions," and social circles grew smaller even as candidates endeavored to attract more and more supporters. … Long before people used the word party, in the sense of "political party," they used the word's meaning of "social event" to suggest political cohesion, as Margaret Bayard Smith did when she spoke of having a "right down Crawford party, " a "party" of "fifteen or twenty" theatergoers--"senators and members"--assembled to show public support for ["her candidate"] William Crawford.

In the gendered world of the early Republic, social events were considered women's work, no matter what their political uses might have been. . . .As a result of Washington City's peculiar needs in that era, women found themselves central personages, sometimes to their delight and other times to their distress. . . .Louisa Catherine's ambivalence took the same (though exaggerated) form as that of other politically connected elite women: denying or disclaiming any interest in or taste for politics, usually immediately before engaging in a political discussion or action.

In spite of regarding these duties as "literally. . .the torments of my life," she turned society into a science…. Large parties and balls had always been part of her social campaign, but "Mrs. Adams's Tuesday nights" served quite a different purpose… . Though it might seem that Louisa Catherine's regularly scheduled soirees evolved naturally from the practice of giving frequent parties, she quite consciously instituted the subscription aspect that made them different and aroused controversy. In December 1819 she mentioned that she "open[ed] my campaign, having given a general invitation for every Tuesday during the winter."

http://www.upress.virginia.edu/books/allgor_excerpts.html

Revised 10/11/00