“But for Birmingham,” Fred Shuttleworth recalled
President John F. Kennedy saying in June 1963 when he invited
black leaders to meet with him, “we would not be here today.”
Birmingham is well known for its civil rights history, particularly
for the violent white-on-black bombings that occurred there in
the 1960s, resulting in the city’s nickname “Bombingham.”
What is less well known about Birmingham’s racial history,
however, is the extent to which early city planning decisions
influenced and prompted the city’s civil rights protests.
The first book-length work to analyze this connection, "The
Most Segregated City in America": City Planning and Civil
Rights in Birmingham, 1920–1980 uncovers the impact
of Birmingham’s urban planning decisions on its black communities
and reveals how these decisions led directly to the civil rights
movement.
Spanning over sixty years, Charles E. Connerly’s study
begins in the 1920s, when Birmingham used urban planning as an
excuse to implement racial zoning laws, pointedly sidestepping
the 1917 U.S. Supreme Court Buchanan v. Warley decision
that had struck down racial zoning. The result of this obstruction
was the South’s longest-standing racial zoning law, which
lasted from 1926 to 1951, when it was redeclared unconstitutional
by the U.S. Supreme Court. Despite the fact that African Americans
constituted at least 38 percent of Birmingham’s residents,
they faced drastic limitations to their freedom to choose where
to live. When in the1940s they rebelled by attempting to purchase
homes in off-limit areas, their efforts were labeled as a challenge
to city planning, resulting in government and court interventions
that became violent. More than fifty bombings ensued between 1947
and 1966, becoming nationally publicized only in 1963, when four
black girls were killed in the bombing of the Sixteenth Street
Baptist Church.
Connerly effectively uses Birmingham’s history as an example
to argue the importance of recognizing the link that exists between
city planning and civil rights. His demonstration of how Birmingham’s
race-based planning legacy led to the confrontations that culminated
in the city’s struggle for civil rights provides a fresh
lens on the history and future of urban planning, and its relation
to race.
Charles E. Connerly is William G. and Budd
Bell Professor of Urban and Regional Planning at Florida State University.