You are here

Murder, Honor, and Law

Four Virginia Homicides from Reconstruction to the Great Depression
Richard F. Hamm

BUY Cloth · ISBN 9780813922072 · $60.00 · Jun 2003
BUY Paper · ISBN 9780813922089 · $23.50 · Jun 2003

In 1868 a scion of one of the leading families of Richmond, Virginia, ambushed and killed the city’s most controversial journalist over an article that had dishonored the killer’s family. In 1892 a Democratic politician killed a crusading Danville minister after a dispute at the polls. In 1907 a former judge shot to death the son of the Nelson County sheriff for an alleged rape, and in 1935 an Appalachian schoolteacher stood accused of killing her father by beating him with a shoe. All of these killers stood trial; two were convicted and two were acquitted. These cases attracted extensive press coverage, and journalists became not only recorders of the stories but integral parts of them, constructing the meaning of the events as they occurred and blurring the lines between reporter and reported.

Journalists from outside the state in their coverage of these cases provoked Virginians, and especially the press, to explain the interaction of their social values and legal system. In Murder, Honor, and Law, Richard F. Hamm explores the contrasts between how and to what effect national, particularly northern, newspapers perceived and portrayed Virginia law and custom versus how local papers covered the same events. In each of the cases Hamm shows the interplay of national media and culture with southern law, values, and culture and highlights how newspapers accepted, produced, altered, and disseminated ideas of southern exceptionalism, especially ideas about honor and chivalry. By focusing on the evolving press coverage of a number of crimes and trials over seventy years, Hamm illuminates the shift in southerners’ defenses against northern criticism from a position of pride in a society in which honor could trump law to claims that the South was just as law-abiding as the rest of the nation. He thus illustrates some key aspects for transformations of southern exceptionalism.

The American South Series


Hamm (Univ. of Albany, SUNY) examines four murder trials that occurred in Virginia between 1868 and 1935. In each instance, he recounts the details of the crime and resulting criminal proceedings from the perspective of local, regional, and national newspaper coverage and appraises the impact that ‘honor’ had on the verdicts. Additionally, the author's analyses of newspaper coverage provide case studies focusing on the sourthern exceptionalism theme. All of this could overwhelm even the most determined reader, but Hamm's careful attention to context provides unity as the text moves from trial to trial. College and university libraries supporting academic programs in journalism or mass communications will want this book for what it reveals about the development of the US newspaper industry.... Hamm's book is an essential purchase for academic or public libraries with Virginia history collections; it will also enhance any southern history collection.


About the Author(s): 

Richard F. Hamm, Associate Professor of History at the University at Albany, State University of New York, is the author of Shaping the Eighteenth Amendment: Temperance Reform, Legal Culture, and the Polity, 1880–1920, winner of the 1996 Henry Adams Prize from the Society for History in the Federal Government.

Interested in this topic?
Stay updated with our newsletters:

Related Books