
Without the Novel
No genre manifests the pleasure of reading—and its power to consume and enchant—more than romance. In suspending the category of the novel to rethink the way prose fiction works, Without the Novel demonstrates what literary history looks like from the perspective of such readerly excesses and adventures.
Rejecting the assumption that novelistic realism is the most significant tendency in the history of prose fiction, Black asks three intertwined questions: What is fiction without the novel? What is literary history without the novel? What is reading without the novel? In answer, this study draws on the neglected genre of romance to reintegrate eighteenth-century British fiction with its classical and Continental counterparts. Black addresses works of prose fiction that self-consciously experiment with the formal structures and readerly affordances of romance: Heliodorus’s Ethiopian Story, Cervantes’s Don Quixote, Fielding’s Tom Jones, Sterne’s Tristram Shandy, and Burney’s The Wanderer. Each text presents itself as a secondary, satiric adaptation of anachronistic and alien narratives, but in revising foreign stories each text also relays them. The recursive reading that these works portray and demand makes each a self-reflexive parable of romance itself. Ultimately, Without the Novel writes a wider, weirder history of fiction organized by the recurrences of romance and informed by the pleasures of reading that define the genre.
- Jayne Elizabeth Lewis, University of California, Irvine, author of Air’s Appearance: Literary Atmosphere in British Fiction, 1660-1794"An original, adventurous, and effervescent study of the pleasures of romance in the age of the novel’s endlessly revisited rise."
- Marcie Frank, Concordia University, author of The Novel Stage: Narrative Form from the Restoration to Jane Austen"Important and timely, this beautifully executed thought-experiment has wide implications for literary studies."
- Modern Philology"Black's compelling study challenges scholars to rethink approaches to the study of literature, interrogating both the linearity of literary history and the historicist gaze of literary criticism."
- SEL Studies in English Literature"Scott Black argues, in his Without the Novel: Romance and the History of Prose Fiction, that our thinking about the eighteenth-century novel has been hampered by a blind spot and an unwarranted assumption. The blind spot is our tendency to overlook the affinities between the early novel and romance. The unwarranted assumption is the conviction that it was the destiny of the eighteenth-century novel to eventuate in realism.... [Black's] focus on romance, and on the different kind of reading it encourages, genuinely pays off here."
Scott Black is Professor of English at the University of Utah and the author of Of Essays and Reading in Early Modern Britain.
1. Reading Mistakes in Heliodorus
2. The Origins of Romance
3. Romance Redivivus
4. The Adventures of Love in Tom Jones
5. Tristram Shandy's Strange Loops of Reading
6. Stasis and Static in The Wanderer
Coda: Reading Romance

